Submission Review Board

Resources for AIJ Reviewers

These resources are provided to assist you in completing the most thorough and helpful review possible. These methods are not required to be followed, but we strongly encourage that both new and seasoned reviewers read them to become acquainted with, or brush up on, proper reviewing techniques.

Books

Dane, F C. (2011). Evaluating research. methodology for people who need to read research . Los Angeles: Sage Publications.

Girden, E R. & Kabacoff, R I. (2011). Evaluating research articles from start to finish. Los Angeles: Sage Publications.

Online Articles

Campion, M. A. (1993, September). ARTICLE REVIEW CHECKLIST: A CRITERION CHECKLIST FOR REVIEWING RESEARCH ARTICLES IN APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY. Personnel Psychology. pp. 705-718. Retrieved from EBSCOhost.

Roediger, H. L. (2007, April). Twelve tips for reviewers. The Academic Observer. http://www.psychologicalscience.org/observer/getArticle.cfm?id=2157

Bengtson, V. L. & MacDermid, S M. . (2003, May 05). How to review a journal article: suggestions for first time reviewers and reminders for seasoned experts. Retrieved from http://bear.warrington.ufl.edu/centers/MKS/marketing%20science/link1.pdf

Pannell, D.J. (2006). Reviewing journal articles, Discussion Paper, School of Agricultural and Resource Economics, University of Western Australia, http://dpannell.fnas.uwa.edu.au/reviews.htm

Reviewer List: Volume 3, Issue 1

  • Dr. Azadeh Osanloo, New Mexico State University, New Mexico
  • Dr. Barbara Carter, Oklahoma City Community College, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Bin Shao, West Texas A&M University, Texas
  • Dr. Biqing Huang, Angelo State University, Texas
  • Ms. Bonnie Peterson, Washburn University, Kansas
  • Dr. C. Matt Seimears, Emporia State University, Kansas
  • Dr. Carlos Price, University of Houston- Clear Lake, Texas 
  • Dr. Cynthia Bostick, California State University, California
  • Dr. David Reavis, Texas A&M University- Texarkana, Texas
  • Dr. James Utterback, Seminole State College, Oklahoma
  • Dr. John Wood, Rose State College, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Joy Patton, University of North Texas- Dallas, Texas
  • Dr. Justin Walton, Cameron University, Oklahoma
  • Ms. Kanwal Gagneja, Bemidji State University, Minnesota
  • Dr. Kathleen Fite, Texas State University, Texas
  • Dr. Kerry Roberts, Stephen F. Austin State University, Texas
  • Mr. Krishna Bista, Arkansas State University, Arkansas  
  • Dr. Louella Moore, Washburn University, Kansas
  • Dr. Mark Horacek, University of Saint Mary, Kansas
  • Dr. Mark Riney, West Texas A&M University, Texas
  • Dr. MaryCarol Pomatto, Pittsburg State University, Kansas
  • Dr. Melody Knight, Texas A&M University- Kingsville, Texas
  • Dr. Nancy Hill, Southeastern Oklahoma State University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Natalie Johnson-Leslie, Arkansas State University, Arkansas
  • Dr. Renee Nank, University of Texas- San Antonio, Texas
  • Dr. Richard Rose, West Texas A&M University, Texas 
  • Dr. Rosalie Otters, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. Roxanne Cuellar, Texas State University- San Marcos, Texas
  • Dr. Shirley Mills, University of Texas- Pan American, Texas  
  • Dr. Shishu Zhang, University of the Incarnate Word, Texas
  • Dr. Steve Bounds, Arkansas State University, Arkansas
  • Dr. Suzanne Thomas, Texas A&M University- Commerce, Texas
  • Dr. Thomas Coroll, Midland College, Texas
  • Dr. Vickie Kelly, Washburn University, Kansas
  • Dr. Zhidong Zhang, The University of Texas at Brownsville, Texas

Reviewer List: Volume 2, Issue 2

  • Dr. Angela Lumpkin, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas
  • Dr. Barba Patton, University of Houston- Victoria, Houston, Texas
  • Dr. Bernnell Peltier-Glaze, Texas Southern University, Houston, Texas
  • Dr. Bronwyn Macfarlane, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. Carlos G. Price, University of Houston- Clear Lake, Houston, Texas
  • Dr. Carolyn Mosley, University of Arkansas- Fort Smith, Fort Smith, Arkansas
  • Dr. Carrie Boden-Mcgill, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. David Briscoe, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. Deborah Kenny, University of Colorado at Colorado Springs, Colorado Springs, Colorado
  • Dr. Earnestyne L. Walter-Sullivan, Prarie View A&M University, Prarie View, Texas
  • Dr. Ed Cunliff, University of Central Oklahoma, Edmond, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Eileen E. Morrison, Texas State University, San Marcos, Texas
  • Dr. Howard Smith, Pittsburgh State University, Pittsburgh, Kansas
  • Dr. John Trice, University of Central Arkansas, Conway, Arkansas
  • Dr. John Wood, Rose State College, Guthrie, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Joy Patton, University of North Texas- Dallas, Dallas, Texas
  • Dr. Justin Walton, Cameron University, Lawton, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Kent Eaton, McPherson College, McPherson, Kansas
  • Dr. Kerry Roberts, Stephen F. Austin State University, Nacogdoches, Texas
  • Dr. Mary Carol Pomatto, Pittsburgh State University, Pittsburgh, Kansas
  • Dr. Mary Prentice, New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, New Mexico
  • Dr. Max Frazier, Newman University, Wichita, Kansas
  • Dr. Melinda A. Wilkins, Arkansas Tech University, Russellville,  Arkansas
  • Dr. Mo Cuevas, West Texas A&M University, Canyon, Texas
  • Dr. Nora Clark, Washburn University, Topeka, Kansas
  • Dr. Omar Al Nasser, University of Houston- Victoria, Houston, Texas
  • Dr. Paul A. Stock, University of Mary Hardin-Baylor, Belton, Texas
  • Dr. Paul Sale, University of Texas- Pan American, Edinburg, Texas
  • Dr. Paula Schornick, Northeastern Oklahoma State University, Claremore, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Peggy S. Hart Miller, East Central University, Argyle, Texas
  • Dr. Robert Maninger, Sam Houston State University, Huntsville, Texas
  • Dr. Ronald W. Maestas, New Mexico Highlands University, Las Vegas, New Mexico
  • Dr. Scott Newman, Oklahoma State University Institute of Technology, Okmulgee, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Thomas Corll, Midland College, Midland, Texas
  • Dr. Timothy Michael, University of Houston- Clear Lake, Houston, Texas
  • Dr. Tonnie Martinez, Kansas State University, Manhattan, Kansas
  • Dr. Tracey Rockett, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, Texas
  • Dr. Vickie Shamp Ellis, Oklahoma Baptist University, Shawnee, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Vimal K. Aggarwal, Gian Jyoti Institute of Management and Technology, Chandigarh, Indiana
  • Mr. Jeffrey Aulgur, Arkansas Tech University, Russellville,  Arkansas
  • Mrs. Amanda Nydegger, Baylor University, Waco, Texas
  • Mrs. Kathy Collins, Ouachita Baptist University, Arkadelphia, Arkansas
  • Mrs. Rebecca Goza, University of Central Oklahoma, Edmond, Oklahoma
  • Ms. Mitzi Efurd Health Science/Dental Hygiene Fort Smith, Arkansas

Reviewer List: Volume 2, Issue 1

  • Dr. Jim beard, University of Arkansas-Fort Smith, Arkansas
  • Dt. Timothy Michael, University of Houston-Clear Lake, Texas
  • Dr. Mary Prentice, New Mexico State University, New Mexico
  • Dr. Azadeh Osanloo, New Mexico State University, New Mexico
  • Dr. MaryCarol Pomatto, Pittsburg State University, Kansas
  • Mrs. Amanda Nydegger, Baylor University, Texas
  • Mrs. Kathy Collins, Oklahoma Baptist University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. David Briscoe, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. Erika Derkas, New Mexico Highlands University, New Mexico
  • Dr. Julie Cowgill, Oklahoma City University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Ed Cunliff, University of Central Oklahoma, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Melinda A. Wilkins, Arkansas Tech University, Arkansas
  • Dr. Michael F. Shaughnessy, Eastern New Mexico University, New Mexico
  • Dr. Brett Andrews, Oklahoma Wesleyan University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Dana Moore Gray, Rogers State University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Vimal K. Aggarwal, Gian Jyoti Institute, India
  • Dr. Kathy Hill, Sam Houston State University, Texas
  • Dr. Peggy S. Hart Miller, East Central University, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Robert G. Harrington, University of Kansas, Kansas
  • Dr. Renee Nank, University of Texas- San Antonio, Texas
  • Dr. Nora Clark, Washburn University of Topeka, Kansas
  • Dr. Tracy Rockett, University of Texas at Dallas, Texas
  • Dr. Beata Krupa, Rice University, Texas
  • Dr. Julie Lamb Milligan, Arkansas State University
  • Dr. John Trice, University of Central Arkansas, Arkansas
  • Mrs. Ginger L. Holloway, Northwest Arkansas Community College, Arkansas
  • Dr. Spencer Weiler, University of Northern Colorado, Colorado
  • Dr. Frances R. Vlasses, Loyola University Chicago, Illinois
  • Dr. Angela Lumpkin, University of Kansas, Kansas
  • Dr. Susan J. Nix, West Texas A&M University, Texas
  • Dr. Mo Cuevas, West Texas A&M University, Texas
  • Dr. Robert Maninger, Sam Houston State University, Texas
  • Dr. Sydney Fulbright, University of Arkansas-Fort Smith, Arkansas
  • Dr. Joy Patton, University of North Texas-Dallas, Texas
  • Mrs. Michele Delawder, John Brown University, Arkansas
  • Ms. Mitzi Efurd, University of Arkansas-Fort Smith, Arkansas
  • Dr. Spencer C. Weiler, University of Northern Colorado, Colorado
  • Dr. Howard Smith, Pittsburg State University, Kansas
  • Mr. Rizwan Danish, University of the Punjab, Pakistan
  • Dr. Linda Trujilo, Kansas State University, Kansas
  • Dr. Jennifer D.M. Cook, University of the Incarnate Word, Texas
  • Dr. Kathleen Fite, Texas State University, Texas
  • Dr. Linda Challoo, Texas A&M University-Kingsville, Texas
  • Dr. Steve Bounds, Arkansas State University, Arkansas
  • Dr. Juan Garcia, University of Texas at Brownsville, Texas
  • Dr. Amy Williamson, Angelo State University, Texas
  • Dr. John Wood, Rose State College, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Cheryl Evans, University of Central Oklahoma, Oklahoma
  • Dr. Michelle Abrego, University of Texas at Brownsville, Texas
  • Mr. Robert T. Mooney, Texas State University, Texas
  • Dr. Bennie Prince, University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Arkansas
  • Dr. Alma Jackson, Mesa State College, Colorado
  • Dr. Paul A. Stock, University of Mary Hardin-Baylor, Texas
  • Dr. Lynn Hemmer, Texas A&M International University, Texas
  • Dr. Cynthia M. Chovich, Mesa State College, Colorado
  • Mrs. Sabrina Waters, University of Arkansas, Arkansas
  • Ms. Jo Ellen Greischar-Billiard, University of Kansas, Kansas
  • Dr. Sribhagyam Srinivasan, Lamar State College-Orange, Texas
  • Dr. Earnestyne L. Walter-Sullivan, Prairie View A&M University, Texas
  • Dr. Shirley J. Mills, University of Texas Pan American, texas
  • Dr. Eileen E. Morrison, Texas State University, Texas

Archives: 2011

aij-twitter aij-facebook

Dr. Tami Moser, Editor-in-Chief
100 Campus Drive, STF 345
Weatherford, OK 73096
(580) 774-7175
aij@swosu.edu